Tylenol vs. Aspirin: Which is More Effective?

Tylenol and Aspirin are the medications that are used to treat pain and fever caused in the body. People widely use both these medications, but the question is, which of the drug is better than the other? Let us know more about it.

What is Tylenol?

Tylenol is a drug used as a medication for muscle pain and fever. Acetaminophen is the generic name of Tylenol. You can buy Tylenol over the counter from a certified online pharmacy.

Tylenol belongs to the drug class called Analgesics and Antipyretics. IT is an oral medication available in the form of tablets (James, L.P., Mayeux, P.R. and Hinson, J.A., 2003).

What is Aspirin?

Aspirin is used for the treatment of minor pain and fever. It is generically known by the same name and available in the market by many other brand names. It is also an OTC Medication. You can buy Aspirin online from a certified pharmacy.

It belongs to the drug class called Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID), in which it was the first member of the group. It is also known as Salicylate and is available in the form of tablets (Awtry, E.H. and Loscalzo, J., 2000. Aspirin).

Which is More Effective: Tylenol or Aspirin?

Tylenol and Aspirin are both pain relievers and effective against aches and pain. These medications are also used for symptoms of Upper respiratory tract infection (URTI).

Claus Bachert Et.al; conducted a similar study to compare the effectiveness of 500 and 1000 mg Aspirin and Tylenol compared to Placebo in adult patients suffering from URTI.

The trial was conducted in Russia, where 78 people were given Aspirin doses, and 79 people were given Tylenol doses. The remaining 78 people were in the placebo group.

The primary efficacy measure was to check the reduction in body temperature from the dosage to 4 hours. The AUC values of change in temperature were as follows:

• Aspirin 500 mg: 3.18
• Aspirin 1000 mg: 4.26
• Tylenol 500 mg: 3.13
• Tylenol 1000 mg: 4.11
• Placebo: 0.76

Significant reductions in temperature were observed in Aspirin and Tylenol as compared to placebos. Similar efficiency was shown by both Aspirin and Tylenol against the symptoms of fever, pain, and URTI (Bachert C, Chuchalin AG, Eisebitt R. Aspirin compared with acetaminophen in the treatment of fever and other symptoms).

Comparison Between Aspirin and Tylenol

Acetaminophen and Aspirin can be purchased without a prescription. The dosage depends on the condition and the response to the treatment.
The working mechanism and usage of Aspirin and Tylenol are similar, and both these medications show similar side effects.

Talking about Aspirin, it may show more gastrointestinal side effects than Acetaminophen, which can badly affect people suffering from stomach ulcers. In contrast, Acetaminophen can have harmful effects on people suffering from liver diseases. Aspirin is not prescribed to pregnant women and children. At the same time, an increase in the dosage of Tylenol can be harmful to an individual.

It is observed that both Tylenol and Aspirin are equally effective. Even though both medicines are different, they are used for the same purpose and work in the exact mechanism. The selection of any of the drugs depends upon the medical history of the individual. Proper doctor consultation should be taken before taking medication in order to reduce the risk (Tarlin, L., Landrigan, P., Babineau, R. and Alpert, J.J., 1972).